Plant Genetics

What an Indica Label Can Tell You About Aroma

·

A botanist assessing the aroma of a flower in a sample jar.

A flower can smell familiar even when its family tree comes as a surprise. That distinction became especially clear when scientists compared cannabis sold under the names Indica and Sativa. They looked for a pattern in two places: across the plant’s DNA and in the small molecules that give a flower its scent. The second search turned up a clue that the first had largely missed.

Reading a label against a genome

For their 2021 study in Nature Plants, researchers assembled more than a hundred cannabis samples with commercial labels. They measured cannabinoids and terpenes, a large family of chemicals that includes many fragrant molecules. They also read more than a hundred thousand positions in the genome where the DNA sequence can differ from one plant to the next. Those positions allowed them to ask how closely the samples resembled one another, independent of what a supplier called them.

If the names marked two well-separated groups in this collection, samples at opposite ends of the label scale should have looked different across much of the genome. They didn’t. An Indica label did a poor job of placing a sample on a genetic family tree. That finding alone might have made the naming system look arbitrary. The chemical measurements suggested something more interesting was going on.

An earthy scent and a stretch of DNA

The clearest chemical association with an Indica label involved myrcene, a terpene often described as earthy. Samples labelled more strongly Indica tended to contain more of it. Myrcene concentration accounted for roughly a fifth of the variation in labelling within this collection. That figure describes a relationship across samples. It would be a mistake to read it as the probability that someone could identify one flower correctly by smell.

Other associations involved guaiol and two forms of eudesmol. The researchers traced variation in the levels of certain terpenes to regions containing clusters of terpene synthase genes. These genes carry instructions for enzymes that help make the fragrant compounds. Relatives can inherit different versions of a relatively small stretch of DNA while sharing much of the rest. A person who sorts flowers by an aroma could therefore group together plants whose more distant ancestry looks quite different.

Why two genetic studies can sound at odds

An earlier survey of hemp and drug-type cannabis found appreciable genome-wide differences between those broad crop groups. Within the drug-type samples, the researchers also saw a moderate relationship between reported Indica or Sativa ancestry and genetic structure. The two projects sampled different plants and recorded different kinds of information. A statement about a plant’s reported pedigree and a commercial description of its dried flower need not carry equal historical information.

What reaches the nose

A terpene measurement captures only part of a scent. In a separate chemical and sensory study, researchers found distinctive aromas among cannabis samples with broadly similar major terpene profiles. Some of the differences tracked compounds outside the terpene family, including substances present in small quantities. The nose weights molecules by how readily it detects them. A list arranged from highest to lowest concentration follows a different rule.

A study of scent within named cannabis strains compared descriptions from actual sniff tests with genetic information from the same samples. That pairing matters when reading a description. “Earthy” records a sensory impression that someone else could try to recognize. A measured amount of myrcene gives a chemist a specific result to compare. “Indica” can carry a little of that sensory history without specifying either measurement. And none of the genetic tests asked volunteers how sleepy a particular flower made them feel.

Imagine two flowers that share a commercial name and differ across much of their DNA. One might still detect a family resemblance on opening the jars. In that case, what the nose has recognized is a feature of the flowers; establishing a family relationship between the plants takes another kind of evidence.